Rechercher sur ce blogue

vendredi 28 juin 2024

Comment apprécier le test de l'arrêt W.D. quant à l'infraction de conduite dangereuse

R. v. Ibrahim, 2019 ONCA 631 

Lien vers la décision


[63] This approach may be adapted to the context of dangerous driving. One suggested approach would include the following two elements:

(1)   If you accept the accused's evidence and, on the basis of it, you have a reasonable doubt about whether the Crown has satisfied any one of the offence elements required to prove dangerous driving, as I have explained those elements to you, you will find the accused not guilty.

(2)   Even if you do not accept the accused's evidence, if, after considering it alone or in conjunction with the other evidence, you have a reasonable doubt whether the Crown has satisfied any one of the elements required to prove dangerous driving, as I have explained those elements to you, you will find the accused not guilty.

Aucun commentaire:

Publier un commentaire

Le dédommagement à la victime doit toujours être envisagé lors de la détermination de la peine

Il est adéquat pour un juge d'instance de tirer l'inférence que l'accusé a la mens rea nécessaire à la commission de l'infraction lorsque l'ensemble de la preuve est prise en compte

R v Kaiswatum, 2019 SKCA 7  Lien vers la décision [ 53 ]             The sole issue at the trial was whether the Crown had proven the necess...