Rechercher sur ce blogue

lundi 20 janvier 2025

Ce que constitue un acte intermédiaire au sens du lien de causalité

R. v. Berto, 2021 ONCA 839 

Lien vers la décision


[47]      An intervening act is an event independent of the accused’s conduct, that severs the chain of factual causation: Romanoat para. 34. This generally occurs in one of two situations: when either (a) the independent intervening act is not reasonably foreseeable, and/or (b) the intervening act is an independent cause that is significant enough to sever the chain of causation between the accused’s act and the consequence: Romanoat para. 35, citing R. v. Malkowski, 2015 ONCA 887, at para. 14.

[48]      As the Supreme Court held in R. v. Maybin, 2012 SCC 24, [2012] 2 S.C.R. 30, at para. 49, the question is “whether the intervening act is a response to the acts of the accused. In other words, did the act of the accused merely set the scene, allowing other circumstances to (coincidentally) intervene, or did the act of the accused trigger or provoke the action of the intervening party?”


Aucun commentaire:

Publier un commentaire

Le dédommagement à la victime doit toujours être envisagé lors de la détermination de la peine

La réoption n'est pas un événement imprévisible ou inévitable

R. v. Long, 2023 ONCA 679 Lien vers la décision [ 62 ]        I would also observe that the appellant re-elected a trial in the OCJ on Febru...